The Ultimate Question

When I was in middle school one of the well liked students (by teachers and students!), said in passing, “You know Mr. M, the shortest complete statement in the English is, I am.” The science teacher, Mr. M. engaged with this student and listened as he explained that in the sentence, “I” was the subject, and (being) “am” was the action.

Something about his statement didn’t site well with my thirteen year old self, and I think, after nineteen years, I can finally put a finger on what bothered me. To exemplify my explanation, and keep it brief: context. The word context is my complete answer and it is a reasonable one, if you have nineteen years to ponder this situation. A more concise answer is that “I Am.” Whether technically complete or not, is a meaningless phrase with no definition without context. WHAT AM I?

Further, in using just those two words and a period are we not making existence finite? “I am.” in an isolated position, is so permanent, and gives me a feeling of inflexibility. Inflexibility, tied to the lack of context dehumanizes a skill that, so far as research has taught me, is uniquely human. Language. (not to be confused with communication) I may be reading too much Noam Chomsky, and yet I prefer to ask open ended questions like why.

Yes, why my only be answerable some of the time, and it’s flexibility opens those involved up to division. (E.G. Why should there be/not be pet brought into the family?) but in this question there is opportunity for change and a defense of justifiable continuity. The same desire for a sense of definition that can be found in “I am.” is also the reason we have why. We want to know, and is order to to know, we often quash the curiosity of children as a rite of adulthood, but WHY?

šŸ˜‰ SickyBeat

Published by sickybeat

I am a writer with an extremely active imagination. I love learning answers to questions and what makes everything and everyone tick. I am a "Unique case, medically" if nothing else. I am flawed in my extreme aversion to failure (even when "success" isn't good for me,) but have come a long way in ditching the perfectionist mindset. I like people whose default setting toward others is compassion, an open mind, and honesty

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: